fad diet-related stories
Fad Diets Make Obesity Crisis Worse
Photo: aj GAZMEN, flickr
Doctors now warn that celebrity diets are contributing to the obesity epidemic. Think Lemonade, Grapefruit, Tiger, Mayo Clinic, Apple and Cabbage Soup. All of these so-called diets may help you lose weight in the beginning, but can you really stick with them? Only if you don't like food.
Most of these diets have the same thing in common -- they place heavy restrictions on what you can eat. Take the Lemonade Diet (also known as the Master Cleanse) for instance. You mix up a batch of "lemonade" with lemon juice, maple syrup, cayenne pepper and water. With six to 12 glasses allowed each day (no other food), this diet is likely to leave you a little sour. The Cabbage Soup Diet allows you to eat as much of its soup that you want each day along with fruits and vegetables, but it neglects other important food groups which can lead to nutritional deficiencies.
Mayo Clinic Diet Is a Fad
The basic premise of the diet is that dieters should ban all complex carbohydrates, but can eat as much protein and fat as they want. One of the "rules" of the diet even states, "At any meal you may eat until you are full -- until you can't eat any more."
Experts agree that a diet based on unbalanced nutrition and limited food choices, like the one recommended in the Mayo Clinic Diet, can be unhealthy. Plus, the boredom associated with eating the same foods over and over can prompt a return to old eating habits once someone goes off the diet.
The quick weight loss associated with the plan is also unhealthy. A better option than the Mayo Clinic Diet is the Mayo Clinic Healthy Weight Pyramid, a lifestyle plan that includes a variety of healthy foods and daily exercise -- and is actually associated with the Mayo Clinic. It offers personalized menus, shopping lists, meal plans, results charts and dining-out tips.
Learn more about diet hoaxes that can sabotage your weight loss plans and check out That's Fit's Fitness page for tips to get in shape.
Paleo Diet - The Caveman Diet
The American Dietetic Association classifies the paleo diet as a fad diet.
"The caveman diet may have some quick-fix weight-loss effects, but the diet leaves out healthful components of well-balanced eating such as heart-healthy, cholesterol-lowering whole grains, breads and cereals, beans and legumes, and calcium-rich dairy products," says Marissa Lippert, R.D., a New York City nutritionist from Nourish Nutrition Counseling & Communications. "As our agricultural system evolved over thousands of years, so has our bodies' nutrition needs. If we exclude entire nutrient categories from our diet, our energy levels, cravings and general health can be impacted."
If you want to stay healthy and lose weight, the majority of health professionals agree that a reduced-calorie diet that a variety of foods is the healthiest approach.
Don't Fall For Fads
There are lots of do's and don'ts when it comes to dieting, and relying on fad diets is one of the biggest no-nos out there. But just what constitutes a fad diet? Here are a couple of rules of thumb:
- Any diet that makes you cut out one or more food group -- or solid food altogether -- is probably a fad diet (like that Lemonade diet -- ugh).
- Speaking of that, any diet that limits your meals to the same rancid thing over and over again is a fad diet.
- Any diet that that makes you fork out money for pills or special formulas for is a fad diet.
- Any diet that limits you to less than 1,000 calories a day is a fad diet -- and a really dangerous one at that!
- And sorry folks, any diet that promises you'll lose more than a couple of pounds a week is a fad diet.
If you've fallen for these in the past, don't beat yourself up -- celebs like Liz Hurley and Sarah Michelle Gellar have tried the Cabbage Soup Diet just like you. Bottom line? They just don't work. Well, they might, but not in the long run.
Instead, take some healthy advice from Drew Barrymore -- she recently told reporters, "My top beauty and fitness tip is to eat whatever you want in smaller increments but don't starve yourself to societal pressures. And I love to exercise because it makes me feel good about myself." Amen, sister.
Fad diets are so ten years ago
Womens Health, Diet & Weight Loss, Nutrition & Supplements, Men's Health
In the always interesting world of fad diets, turns of phrase like "Lose 10 Pounds in 2 Days!" are tossed about like the salad-only diet you would probably have to follow to really lose that much weight in that short amount of time (only that too wouldn't exactly be healthy weight loss).Thankfully, most people now know that fad diets are about as good for your health as only eating cabbage soup for weeks on end (oh wait ... that actually was a fad diet!!). And, having replaced most of these fads with sound advice on diet and fitness, we can now look back and have a good laugh at many of these ridiculous approaches to weight loss. In fact, I just came across a website that lists just about every fad diet that has swept across the nation in the past ten years or so.
From the Hollywood Diet to the Lemonade Diet (oh yeah, how could I also forget to mention the Amputation Diet!!), FadDiet.com mentions them all. It's nothing overly profound or exciting, but it's at least worth checking out.
5 dangers of fad dieting
- Lack of a balanced diet, or cutting out food groups all together, will lead to nutritional deficiencies
- The lack of variety causes boredom, and based on my experiences with friends on fad diets, extreme moodiness -- yikes!
- The emphasis is on the diet -- it doesn't account for how important exercise is'
- Severely restricting food intake can make it harder to maintain healthy eating habits afterwards.
- Many are based on unsubstantiated claims that can prove to be useless or even harmful.
Fitness: Separating the truth from the lies
Diet & Weight Loss, Fitness, Reviews & Products, Nutrition & Supplements
My fellow That's Fit bloggers and I have made our views on fad diets and the like pretty clear in past posts. A former fitness industry exec has just written a book giving his views and exposing some fad diets, fitness gimmicks, supplements, and exercise equipment as out -and-out lies. Craig Pepin-Donat, the author of The Big, Fat Health and Fitness Lie (Waterside Publishers, $24.95, 258 pages), seems to take a reasonable and moderate stance when it comes to health and fitness; he promotes healthy eating, regular exercise, and monitoring portion sizes. He also stands behind fitness clubs, as long as it's a reputable organization, with good equipment and qualified nutrition and exercise professionals. I haven't read the book yet, but it sounds like a good read to me. I've often wondered about some of the equipment touted on late-night infomercials. I'd never consider buying most of it myself (I'm a try-before-you-buy type of gal when it comes to fitness purchases), but I think it would be interesting to read a review of what those pieces of equipment do... or don't do.
Natasha Bedingfield is latest star to get in The Zone
What do you think of the Zone? Fad or fab?
The Special K challenge: does it work?
Diet & Weight Loss, Reviews & Products
In theory, the challenge should work because it limits your daily calorie intake significantly. But there are several downsides to this. For one, a serving of cereal is not that much (between 1/2 a cup and a full cup) so it may leave you feeling unsatisfied or even still hungry. Secondly, the special K is low in protein and high in sugar and carbs -- which I think sets you on a collision course with an energy crash. Third, how can you get in your 5 to 10 servings a day of fruits and veggies if you're eating cereal for 2 of 3 meals? And fourth, as I mentioned, it's boring.
I think you're better off having a salad for lunch and a healthy, protein-rich breakfast. What do you think?
'Apprentice' contestant developes the 'Bagel Diet'
Diet & Weight Loss, Celebs & Entertainment
All I can say about this 'diet' is Gross! Where are the all-important nutrient-providing fruits and veggies? All you're getting is carbs, processed fat, a small amount of processed protein and the occasional binge day where you're free to consume all the trans and saturated fat you want. And even if it wasn't awful for you, who wants to eat bagel after bagel after bagel? Borrrrrrring.
What do you think?























