
I won't say he's wrong, the author of
Good Calories, Bad Calories: Challenging the Conventional Wisdom on Diet, Weight Control and Disease. I will say I'm intrigued by what he has to say about losing weight -- that it's carbohydrates and not fat and lack of exercise causing Americans to gain weight -- because in my experience, limiting fat and increasing my workouts helped me drop 15 pounds. But hey, maybe I'll give his advice a whirl and see what happens.
Gary Taubes says fat, even the saturated kind, does not cause heart disease. He says that obesity is not caused by eating too much and that exercising is certainly not the key to weight loss. He claims the diet industry is telling us to eat precisely the foods that make us fat, and he declares that carbohydrates engineer our bodies to accumulate fat. The fewer carbs we eat, the leaner we'll be, says this man who vehemently disagrees with diet experts who advise a low-calorie, low-fat plus exercise regime. This approach has a dismal success plan, according to Taubes. Restrict your carbs to 60 grams per day and you'll lose weight -- in one study, weight loss averaged 37 pounds. Go the low-calorie, low-fat route and this study finds you'll lose four.
Here's why cutting carbs works: You burn up the fat you have and store less, stave off insulin resistance, feel less hungry, and have more energy.
Scientific evidence on Taubes' viewpoint is insufficient to recommend or condemn this type of diet, partly because the diets in line with his thinking (like the Atkins diet) are not backed by long-term trials that prove safety.
I kind of like my diet at this moment in time. It's fairly low in calories, fat, and sugar (Taubes does agree sugar is a diet no-no), void of sweets and soda, packed with fruits and veggies, and not so restricted on the carbohydrate front -- although breads, potatoes, and rice don't usually accompany my at-home meals, I do tend to snack on crackers and pretzels and I always go overboard with the bread basket when dining out. And exercise is a staple in my life -- when it comes to the link between exercise and weight loss, I'm a believer.
What do you believe? The reigning wisdom of diet and fitness experts or the controversial wisdom on Taubes?