Bake Sales Get Banned in NYC

Kids in New York City who want to raise money for their sports teams or clubs are going to have to get creative, but not in the kitchen. New regulations have effectively banned bake sales, which, traditionally, are major money makers for school children, according to The New York Times.

In fact, according to the assistant principal of organization at La Guardia High School, a bake sale could bring in $500 in one day -- enough to fund a trip or purchase new uniforms.

The education department actually developed the new wellness policy last year, but it's only now, in the new school year, that the effects are being felt. Other changes include healthier options in school vending machines and restrictions on what can be sold in school stores.

The restriction doesn't ban all junk from schools at all times. Students are still allowed to bring treats for themselves and their classmates, and there is no limit on what kinds of food can be sold during after-school sporting events (because, as The Times points out, it apparently doesn't matter if you're eating cakes and cookies as long as it's after school hours, right?).

While I respect the fact that the education department is taking action to fight childhood obesity, and I think their suggestions to use active fundraisers like walk-a-thons are pretty smart, I also think there has to be a happy medium.

For example, what about limiting bake sales to Friday afternoons, after lunch? That still gives these teams and clubs a chance to earn a bit of money without having fatty baked goods on campus a daily occurrence.

What do you think? Should bake sales be banned, restricted or just left alone?

Hey, at least you're not likely to see this giant cupcake at a school bake sale!