
Fat is the New "Normal"
Categories: Jonny's Take, Diet & Weight Loss
Jonny Bowden, author, nutritionist and weight loss coach cuts through all the misconceptions about diet and fitness to help you transform your body, your health and your life.
Retailers would like to help us remain in a state of denial about our ever-expanding waistlines. They'd like us not to notice how fat we're actually getting.
We don't like facing up to the fact that we're becoming fatter by the minute, and most of us don't particularly like buying "fat clothes." We'd prefer not to notice that those size 8 dresses that used to fit no longer do, or that when we try on those 32-inch waist jeans that used to fit so well, they now feel like they were made for just one of our legs. When that happens, we just don't buy as much. Retailers noticed -- and they have a solution. They changed the sizes.
"In recent years," writes Elizabeth Landau on CNN.com, "brands from the luxury names to the mass retail chains have scaled down the size labels on their clothing," which means "you may actually be a size 14, and, according to whatever particular store you're in, you come out a size 10," says Natalie Nixon, associate professor of fashion industry management at Philadelphia University. Why? Simple. It makes the consumer -- you and me -- feel good.
Participants in the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey for 1988 to 1994 and participants in the survey for 1999 to 2004 were asked to identify themselves as "underweight," "about right" or "overweight," and their answers were compared with the participants' actual BMI, a measure of health risks associated with weight. (You can calculate your BMI here.)
Not surprisingly, the BMI of the general population increased from the early survey period to the later survey period, a good indication that as a population we're getting fatter. (No surprise there.) But the probability of people describing themselves as overweight decreased in the later survey. In other words, folks were significantly less likely to identify themselves as overweight even while they were packing on the pounds.
"Fat" is the new "normal."
Interestingly, women tended to have a slightly more realistic perception of themselves, but this may not necessarily reflect "healthy body image" campaigns. Rather, according to physician nutrition specialist Dr. Melina Jampolis, it's the relative increase in weight of the general population that makes people with normal BMI feel more normal.
But feeling normal while being overweight -- which seems to be the trend -- may decrease a person's motivation to lose weight in the first place. And retailers subtly changing the size so that you don't "notice" that you're now a couple sizes larger than you were a few years ago isn't exactly a good reality check. In fact, it helps keep everyone in denial. It's kind of like grading on a curve in school -- if everyone in the class is getting five out of 10 questions wrong, the person who gets six right earns an A. When it comes to weight, this kind of thinking doesn't do anyone any good. Smoking "only" a pack a day isn't any less of a health risk just because everyone around you is smoking two packs!
Weight loss may be one of the most challenging undertakings most of us can think of, but daunting or not, it's one of the best things we can do for our health, our well-being, our energy and our longevity.
Retailers would like to help us remain in a state of denial about our ever-expanding waistlines. They'd like us not to notice how fat we're actually getting.
We don't like facing up to the fact that we're becoming fatter by the minute, and most of us don't particularly like buying "fat clothes." We'd prefer not to notice that those size 8 dresses that used to fit no longer do, or that when we try on those 32-inch waist jeans that used to fit so well, they now feel like they were made for just one of our legs. When that happens, we just don't buy as much. Retailers noticed -- and they have a solution. They changed the sizes.
"In recent years," writes Elizabeth Landau on CNN.com, "brands from the luxury names to the mass retail chains have scaled down the size labels on their clothing," which means "you may actually be a size 14, and, according to whatever particular store you're in, you come out a size 10," says Natalie Nixon, associate professor of fashion industry management at Philadelphia University. Why? Simple. It makes the consumer -- you and me -- feel good.
Participants in the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey for 1988 to 1994 and participants in the survey for 1999 to 2004 were asked to identify themselves as "underweight," "about right" or "overweight," and their answers were compared with the participants' actual BMI, a measure of health risks associated with weight. (You can calculate your BMI here.)
Not surprisingly, the BMI of the general population increased from the early survey period to the later survey period, a good indication that as a population we're getting fatter. (No surprise there.) But the probability of people describing themselves as overweight decreased in the later survey. In other words, folks were significantly less likely to identify themselves as overweight even while they were packing on the pounds.
"Fat" is the new "normal."
Interestingly, women tended to have a slightly more realistic perception of themselves, but this may not necessarily reflect "healthy body image" campaigns. Rather, according to physician nutrition specialist Dr. Melina Jampolis, it's the relative increase in weight of the general population that makes people with normal BMI feel more normal.
But feeling normal while being overweight -- which seems to be the trend -- may decrease a person's motivation to lose weight in the first place. And retailers subtly changing the size so that you don't "notice" that you're now a couple sizes larger than you were a few years ago isn't exactly a good reality check. In fact, it helps keep everyone in denial. It's kind of like grading on a curve in school -- if everyone in the class is getting five out of 10 questions wrong, the person who gets six right earns an A. When it comes to weight, this kind of thinking doesn't do anyone any good. Smoking "only" a pack a day isn't any less of a health risk just because everyone around you is smoking two packs!
Weight loss may be one of the most challenging undertakings most of us can think of, but daunting or not, it's one of the best things we can do for our health, our well-being, our energy and our longevity.
Recent Posts
- Heidi Klum Hits The Runway After Baby (11/20/2009)
- Thanksgiving Dinner Satisfaction And Perfect Portion Control: Time to Celebrate (11/20/2009)
- Cheesy Workout Video Round-up (11/20/2009)
- Kim Kardashian's Sexy Salad Commercial (11/20/2009)
- Simple Thanksgiving Swaps (11/20/2009)
























Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
wheindl 8-03-2009 @ 2:35PM
Within the past few years, I've lost around 40 lbs., and am able to wear clothing sizes that I wore when I was in my 20's. What I am discovering is not that the sizes themselves have changed, but that retailers are stocking larger sizes. When I was in my 20's, size 30 waists (for men) were very common; now, size 32 is as small as they seem to come, and there's not much selection below size 34. Meanwhile, Medium shirts (15-1/2) were very common when I was in my 20's, and Small (14-1/2) was not hard to find. Now, Medium is often the smallest size stocked, and 2XL (and even 3XL) abound. It seems that Large has become the new Small.
Reply
desireeg00 8-03-2009 @ 2:41PM
This has been my biggest frustration over the years. As a healthy 110 pounds, I've been sized out of most retail stores such as Banana Republic, Express, and New York and Co and find myself now shopping in children's stores. The 0 / 2s purchased 10 years ago are two to three sizes too big now. These stores need to stop contributing to the obesity epidemic and return to their original sizing.
Reply
u262f 8-03-2009 @ 2:44PM
Is smoking still the example you wanted to use if we take into account second-hand smoke? If everybody around you is smoking two packs, second-hand smoke still puts your health at risk even if you don't smoke at all.
Reply
Jaymi 8-04-2009 @ 4:40AM
Ppl need to quit getting fat n start getting healty!! I am a very heallthy person. I'm a size 2-4, I play fastpitch softball and im on the dance team for my school. I don't care for sweet and i love meat, veggies, and fruits. So my future seems to look healthy. But i do understand that everybody has different body shapes. Fat ppl need to stop buying the salt n sugar and yess there is different ways to be happy besides eatting. And we need to keep the kids away from the sweets n sugars also because we don't want to urge on unhealthy eatting habbits..
Reply
Jaymi 8-04-2009 @ 4:44AM
Ppl need to quit getting fat n start getting healty!! I am a very
heallthy person. I'm a size 2-4, 115lbs, I play fastpitch softball and im on the dance team for my school. I don't care for sweet and i love meat, veggies, and fruits. So my future seems to look healthy. But i do understand that everybody has different body shapes. Fat ppl need to stop buying the salt n sugar and yess there is different ways to be happy besides eatting. And we need to keep the kids away from the sweets n sugars also because we don't want to urge on unhealthy eatting habbits..this is redickuluss now..
Reply