Virtual exercise no replacement for actual exercise
I finally had a chance to use a Wii. After getting over some initial embarrassment, I had an awful lot of fun! I tried the tennis game and, sadly enough, I'm as bad at virtual tennis as I am on an actual tennis court. While the Wii was certainly more active than playing any other video game system, it wasn't nearly the same type of exercise as a real sport. Both Bev and Bethany have written about the exercise potential in the interactive gaming system before. And, compared to sitting like a lump playing regular video games, the Wii is a great thing. But it doesn't take the place of real exercise. The active games are a great alternative to regular video games. Also, many of the games aren't violence based -- as a parent, I know I appreciate that. They also offer hand-eye coordination benefits. And, for kids (or adults) who aren't active at all, the games may be a stepping stone for developing interest in real sports.
So the Wii isn't a bad thing at all. But don't count time spent playing interactive video games as exercise time. It's just not the same as the real thing. The CDC recommends that kids be physically active for at least an hour every day. So put away the video tennis, grab a racquet, and play a game of REAL tennis with your kids.














Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
4-18-2008 @ 4:30PM
janey said...
I'm not sure if it has been released in all markets yet, but you should look into Wii Fit if you get a chance. I would be really interested in reading a review on that. It's designed to take the active gameplaying nature of the Wii to the level of actually exercising, with a comprehensive system of tracking results.
Reply
4-18-2008 @ 3:46PM
Maggie Vink said...
Janey,
If you click on the links for Bev's and Bethany's articles, both of them discuss Wii Fit. I think it sounds interesting, too.
4-19-2008 @ 10:50PM
marcie0305 said...
Well, I think this is definitely an improvement over the "sit on the floor" variety of home video games, but at the same time I am worried about the disconnect from outdoor activity. I could make an analogy here to indoor gym activity, it's a better choice than sitting around at your desk by far - but ultimately the best choice is outdoor activity where you get the benefit of fresh air and real perspective on the world - singing birds and flowing creeks included :)
~Marcie
http://feedingblackmail.blogspot.com
Reply