That's Fit

Sounds like a really complex combination of problems. And it's so refreshing to read your take on it, which doesn't jump to the conclusion that low birth weight "causes" declines in future adult success.

I see so many articles that confuse things that tend to go together with things that cause each other, it makes me want to scream--or at least grumble. Thanks!

(Crabby hangs out at http://crankyfitness.blogspot.com/, where she is usually much more grouchy than this.)

Reply

Do I think this is true? No. Not hardly. We like to blame everything on "underprivilege".

Reply

Who thinks of these things? My sister was 4 and I was 5lbs and we both graduated high school and own our own homes/cars and have children and people say we look younger than our age. Who are the people they poll? 12,000 people over 35years? OKIE THEN.

Reply

well, i don't know if this is true. i come from a very poor background and i was born overweight ( 9 pounds and 3/4 ounces) but then again i am doing well in college so of course i didn't drop out..i don't know if i believe this. the article didn't explain the opposite effects, like beign overweight. there wasn't enough info in this article to convince me.

Reply

This is so absurd. My twins were less than 2 lbs when they were born due to prengancy related problems. They are now 8 years old and in the top of their classes. They are ranked above average academically. What does low birth weight have to do with how well you succeed when your older.

Reply

My daughter weight 5lbs.3oz. she has a very good job at top with General Motors, so I say this isn't true.

Reply

I am not sure????? My husband was 4lbs and he was also breach. He is a part owner of successful multi-million $ business. He did not fall into the company he helped build it from the start.

Reply

My grandchildren are twins, the boy was 7lb 14oz has adhd & odd, fair grades but will never be a honor student, my granddauther was 4lb 12oz has been in the top of her class for 5yrs, this past year, she had honor classes, what do you think? I don't beleive the study.

Reply

The findings of this study do not surprise me.

There is a metabolic explanation for the connection between low birth weight and later-life health and functional impairment. It has to do with something called metabolic syndrome. Low birth weight is one of the many factors that predisposes to metabolic syndrome. Interestingly, some other factors include prenatal nutritional deficiencies and emotional stress.

I wrote an article on the subject five years ago: http://drdebe.com/metabolicsyndrome.html

I believe that low-birth increases the likelihood of poor health. However, there are many other influences and lifestyle factors that can change one's health for the better.

Reply

My second son was a premie at 3.12 and he finished high school, went to college, owns his own home and has a wonderful marriage. The only debt he has is his home - vehicles are paid for and credit cards are paid in full each month. I am sure there are a lot of folks who weighed over 5 pounds at birth cannot make that statement!!

Reply

who comes up with this stuff I was 5lbs and I own my home and cars and I run a farm. and have kids one who was 5lbs and the other was 10lbs and the 10lbs has more colds than the other

Reply

Someone please tell me that as a taxpayer I did not help pay for such a stupid survey. What was the birth weight of the people that decided to take this survey.

Reply

Thank you, poster #13. You are absolutely correct.

Reply

Please, actually READ the article before commenting on it. Better yet, follow the link provided and get the actual study highlights and you will see that the author isn't just pondering whether low-birth weight corresponds with poorer life outcomes, and why, but is explaining that a study has been conducted demonstrating that there is indeed a connection between low-birth weight and poorer life outcome (notwithstanding the handful of anecdotal exceptions noted in the comments here--a number so small as to be statistically insignificant). Just because you or your mother (son, aunt, next door neighbor, etc.) was a low birth weight infant and turned out OK does not disprove the validity of the study or the conclusions of its authors. You are simply highlighting individual instances that don't fit the pattern (and likely don't fit other details of the pattern--maybe, for example, you were low birth weight not because your mother failed to get prenatal care or had poor nutrition, but for some medical reason that didn't compromise your underlying health).

Reply

boy thats a kicker no matter how small or big you are what you are is 5 pounds or 12 pounds an 20 years later all that is what you were now what you did in between is what you did do you follow me hollar

Reply

I personally don't agree with parts of this article. In many cases, premature babies have higher intelligence. However, I see how this could make sense. People too young to have babies have babies (generally prematurely) and then don't know how to raise them or how to teach them the things they need to know. As for the health issue, I do agree with that, as many of the people I know born with a low birth weight (including myself) seem more susceptibile to allergies, asthma, colds, etc. However, of course, there are always exceptions to every situation.

Reply

I have to say this is a crock of crap! I was born at 4.3 lbs. lost a pound , had pneumonia, and had to stay in the hospital for months until I weighed 6 lbs. when I was born..... Not only did I rank #8 in highschool out of 800 students, I have a college degree and I'm working on my master's degree. The only debt I have is student loans which I am paying back, Not to mention, I make 6 figures....... so this is B.S.
*Oh yeah and I take vitamins everyday so I have have been also blessed with great health no trace of cancer, diabetes, high blood pressure, high cholestorol nor hypoglicemia*
I think we all need to be in the science profession so we can get numerous grants to make up dumb research everyday and never go out of a job and end up with good retirements..... scientist and research folks might be smart after all.....

Reply

false. my son was 4.3 at birth and we were not financially stable for many years. and both my boys are equally sucessful.

Reply

Sorry but that is a crock. I am a twin. Both my sister and myself were born under 5.5. Did the study take twins into account. Are all twins less likely to be successful? I think the researchers slipped up on that one.

Reply

I don't believe that low birth weight has much to do with not being successful I weighted in a 5 lb 2 ozs at birth. Did very well in school, have a masters and own a very successful business. My son weighted in at 4 lb 13 ozs and has been quite successful in his life also. So I question this study.

Reply