How did this woman lose weight? She got a dog!

it's pretty irresponsible to cite dogs as weight-loss tools, given the huge responsibility they are, and the number of the them already in shelters because people get them for the wrong reasons and find they don't have the time, money, patience or skills to care for them. you could really do some damage with a post like this i hope you'll consider taking it down.

reply

I have a cat, and I'm pretty darn sure no one's ever going to write a book called "the cat diet." Unless sleeping all day turns out to have unexpected metabolic benefits.

I think getting a dog, for someone who really wants one anyway, could be really helpful--it's harder to make excuses to your new best friend who's dependant you for his or her own exercise.

But just like people buy gym equipment and never use it, it could also be a Really Bad Idea for someone lukewarm about a dog to get one just hoping it will magically melt off the pounds. Not fair to the dog. And like you said, there are plenty of overweight people with pooches.

PS--looking forward to when it's your turn on "meet the bloggers." Martha's fitness secrets revealed!


Crabby does her grousing at http://crankyfitness.blogspot.com/

reply

Orthac,
Though you have a good point about the problem of people who adopt dogs and don't have time for them, I don't think Martha is advocating that. (Or me either). She's just reporting on a book someone's written about the ways dogs may help people lose weight. And Martha doesn't seem to me to be endorsing it one way or another. (In fact she sounds skeptical to me).

It's awful when people run out and buy dalmations or whatever based on a movie they saw, without really thinking it through. But do you ban movies about cute dogs? To say that dogs can help people lose weight isn't irresponsible, if it's true. I think the responsibilty lies with the people who actually do the dog dumping, not the people who talk about the benefits having dogs can bring.

reply

Hi there,
Crabby's right ... I don't condone buying a dog to lose weight -- doing so would be irresponsible, in my opinion. But the article and the book it's based on will still exist regardless of this post, so I don't think removing it is necessary.

However, I think this woman's story is an exception -- in most cases getting a pet won't lead to weight loss. Too often I see dogs that are neglected, overweight, under exercised or all three. Such cases are incredibly sad, so I would never encourage someone to get a pet unless they are willing to take on the responsibility of having one.
Thanks for reading!
Martha

reply